Why Med School costs over $200,000 and why it should not

23 06 2009

Bruce Friedman over at LabSoft News had an interesting post today about the current state of affordability of medical school and what we can do to change it.

He first references an article published by the AMA about this topic:

“Medical students who went into debt could figure on owing $126,714 in 2007 on average, up from $88,331 in 2000, according to the Association of American Medical Colleges… Suggestions under consideration would take approval by powers greater than the AMA. They include providing tax deductibility for tuition and loans, and expanding state and federal scholarship opportunities. But another cost-cutting approach is investigating ways to reduce the length of medical schooling—perhaps through competency-based curriculums, or through combined B.A./M.D. programs.”

The article also goes on to say that 23% of medical students graduate with over $200,000 in debt (let’s not forget that you have to go to college first!).  In fact, my personal educational loan grand total was greater than $250,000 when I graduated, and after two years of interest, I’m almost afraid to see where it is now.

Dr. Friedman then goes on to offer his suggestions as to a solution:

  • “Medical schools should begin to accept students, as in former years, after three years if they have fulfilled all of their undergraduate course requirements. If this is impossible given the number of such prerequisites, this number should be reduced such that it is possible for most applicants to quality for the new program.
  • On a selective basis, medical school should allow some students to skip their fourth year and graduate in three. This should only be an option for the most mature students who have amply demonstrated their ability to function well as they pursue their post-graduate medical training. “

My response is as follows:
As a graduate from a combined college/med school program myself, I feel like I have some insight to share on this.  Where I went to med school they had 3 combined programs, mine was 8 years, and there was a 7-year and a 6-year program as well.  IMHO, those ‘kids’ who had only 2 years of college, while they may have been very bright, some of them were wayyyyy to immature for medicine (one of them had a breakdown, actually, and dropped out).  Having said that, however, to pick medical students worthy of graduating early based on their ‘maturity’ is vague and subjective, and, I think, ultimately not fair.

The issue of debt from education is undeniable, and GP is suffering as a result, for sure. And, while I think cutting years is a clever approach, I just don’t think it’s the answer.  Personally, I think the direct approach is the best here. Can ANYONE explain to me why med school was $55,000 a year for me? Sure people always say, “Well, you’ll be good for it in 8 years” or whatever, but that’s really not ok.  My medical school was one building, with quite a finite list of teachers and services, yet it cost twice as much as college and didn’t come with room OR board!  During my tenure as a medical student, we actually approached our dean about the outrageousness of the tuition (I think we were 3rd in the country for most expensive medical school at the time), and the fact that the tuition was continuing to go up almost yearly. Well, he sat our whole class down and showed us a 100-foot pie chart of our expenses.  And with that, we had our answer.  Now, I’m not 100% sure I’m recalling this EXACTLY, but if memory serves me: about 30% of our tuition went to float the hospital’s pro-bono work.  Is this true elsewhere?  I was outraged, we all were.  Absolutely, these people need to be cared for, but to place the burden of the medical students’ shoulders is grossly inappropriate.  In addition to this, we also had to pay a multi-thousand dollar ‘national security fee’ or something of like.  Unreal.  In the end we all just sucked it up, but it’s not ok. Things need to be fixed or the system will collapse in on itself.

Nobody likes people that complain and then don’t offer an alternative, so here are my ideas:

  1. My medical school is as expensive as it is because we have one of the WORST endowments in the country. There should be more focus on giving back, in the form of alumni office activity, and also, you attendings out there should do your parts!!
  2. If I decide to go to med school, I should be paying for my education and not ER work for the uninsured.  I suppose this could be fixed by adopting a nationalized health care system, but I’m not about to open that can of worms. Again, I’m not sure if this situation is recapitulated elsewhere in the country, but there must be some shenanigans to justify $55,000 a year.
  3. Go to a state school or live in a country outside the US.  LOL.  But seriously, many of my co-residents have ZERO debt because medical school is paid for by the government in their country.  Programs similar to this DO exist in the United States.  First of all, there are the Armed Forces.  Also, there are various programs (most of them in Family Practice, I believe) that will pay for medical school with a X-year contract to practice in underserved areas.  I think these could be some valid alternatives to signing away your soul to some people.

Now, I realize that #3 is a band-aid and not a cure.  But, IMHO, the key is to cutting costs by forcing accountability for tuition fee composition.  Also, I think the AMA is on the right track with tax write-offs and subsidies as well.  I’m not saying medical school should be free (as I think in the end, most of us are successful enough to pay our loans back so we shouldn’t have to burden the country with our educational expenses), but it should be affordable enough that what happens with my graduating class does not continue to happen across the country- we had four people (out of about 120) go on to pursue residencies in Family Medicine.  Four.  And that is just not sustainable.

Some food for thought.
What do you think? 🙂




Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: